Buddy finally catches a fish

Mike says Buddy caught a blue gill.  Mike didn't actually see the capture of the fish but he saw Buddy with his prize.

Buddy at his favorite fishing spot.
It has been an exceedingly unlucky spot but it must be cool under there.
He spends a lot of time watching the water.  

Buddy fishing.  

Could it be?

Looks like a fish to me.  

Buddy enjoying his catch.